Guacamelee review: back from hell

Game Info
Platform PS3, PS Vita, Win, PS4, Xbox One, 360, Wii U
Publisher DrinkBox Studios
Developer DrinkBox Studios
Release Date 2013-04-09

Guacamelee proves that you can have reverence for the past without being consumed by it.

With a structure pulled from exploration-heavy 2D classics like Super Metroid and references to other games from Super Mario Bros. to Castle Crashers, Guacamelee could easily have come across as pandering. But it accomplishes more than cloning the successes of older games.

With Guacamelee, developer Drinkbox Studios demonstrates something greater than a love for its influences. It understands how they work, and explores how to pick apart a well-known formula and twist those pieces into its own unique creation.

You begin Guacamelee as a poor Mexican farmer named Juan, whose boring life is interrupted when the woman he loves is kidnapped by a murderous skeleton named Carlos Calaca. Juan is killed in a botched rescue attempt but finds himself resurrected as a luchador in the realm of the dead. Journeying through the forests, deserts and temples of the surrounding countryside, Juan builds up an arsenal of mystical wrestling powers to take on the dastardly Calaca.


Guacamelee smartly "gates" new areas behind obstacles that only new skills and abilities can overcome, and those new tricks are also added to Juan’s growing combat and platforming repertoire. The headbutt skill destroys yellow blocks but also can be used to send enemies ping-ponging across the screen. The uppercut destroys red blocks and allows you to extend your jump just enough to access some initially out-of-reach ledges. Every upgrade grants the immediate satisfaction of new areas to explore and the extended goal of mastering a new move.

The layered nature of discovering new abilities is aided by some incredible challenges that hold together in large part because of Guacamelee’s tight controls. Juan’s abilities are activated based on the direction you’re pushing the analog stick, and I never had a problem making him do what I needed as quickly as necessary. Players have full air control over Juan, and he can move from one special move into another in any combination.

a consistent, striking visual design informed by Mexican culture makes Guacamelee a joy to explore

Chaining an enemy from a dash to an uppercut to a three-hit combo to a body slam sounds complicated, but I pulled off impressive feats like this consistently once I’d spent time learning each move. Guacamelee is willing to give you so much because it asks so much of you in return. Each new foe — from hammer-wielding skeletal giants to airborne dragons — puts up enough of a fight to make it feel like an accomplishment to take them apart without any trouble a couple of hours later.

Even hours into the game, Guacamelee sometimes slipped into old-school, white-knuckle difficulty. Large stretches of the game provide an approachable challenge, but I discovered bonus areas with brutal, non-stop arenas full of enemies and disappearing platforms that tested my jumping skills more than anything since Mega Man. While those bits are optional, the boss fights also provide a stiff test of skill, requiring intelligent combat and masterful pattern recognition.

Those bosses share the game's consistent, striking visual design informed by Mexican culture that makes it a joy to explore. As Juan gains the ability to swap between the realm of the dead and the land of the living, zones you’ve already gone through take on a new form. Lush forests are transformed into creepy woods full of deteriorating plant-life; stoic temple statues morph into demonic visions. Drinkbox has put an astonishing amount of work into building Guacamelee’s colorful world, and I wanted to witness every inch of it.

Guacamelee is short, but it's all fun and no filler

Other paths

Aside from the main game, Guacamelee features two bonuses of questionable value. First, purchasing Guacamelee on either PlayStation 3 or PlayStation Vita enables you to download it on the other platform with Cross-Buy. As with some previous Cross-Buy games, like the recent Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time, you can upload your save file to the cloud from one platform, then download it on the other and pick up where you left off. With a short and minimally replayable game like Guacamelee, Cross-Buy isn’t a massive addition, but it works fine if you have both systems and plan to switch between the TV and the Vita often.

The co-op option has less appeal. While a second player can jump in at any time, they can only do so locally. Even if you have a friend ready to join you on the couch, Guacamelee’s brand of difficult platforming and thoughtful exploration doesn’t seem well-suited to co-op play. The co-op option doesn’t take anything away from Guacamelee, but it doesn’t add much either.

Even for completionists, though, Guacamelee doesn’t overstay its welcome. The near-flawless pace guaranteed that every time I felt like I fully understood how to use an ability, another was just around the corner. Room setups aren’t overused for combat or platforming. I never hit a point where I felt like Drinkbox had run out of ideas. Guacamelee is relatively short as a consequence, but it's all fun and no filler.

Wrap Up:

Guacamelee succeeds on its own merits as something greater than homage

There are plenty of retro-themed 2D releases mining 8- and 16-bit nostalgia and concepts, but very few are crafted with Guacamelee’s expertise. If you stripped away the knowing winks at other games, it would still be noteworthy. The team at Drinkbox has studied the greats, but they've forged their own path with a consistent, engaging art style, and meticulously perfected controls and level design. This passion for Drinkbox’s influences has produced more than homage; Guacamelee is remarkable on its own.

Guacamelee was reviewed using pre-release final PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita download code provided by Drinkbox Studios. Read more about Polygon's ethics policy here.

About Polygon's Reviews

Score History

9.0 PS4
9.0 Xbox One
9.0 360
9.0 Wii U
NEW! Update: 07/01/2014

Guacamelee review update: Super Turbo Championship Edition

Whenever I see a developer adding new content to a game that was already fantastic, I start to worry. Would I like more Guacamelee? Of course, especially considering how short the original game was. But what if they screw it up?

If you share those fears, allow them to wash away in the light of this excellent addition to DrinkBox Studios' colorful action-platformer. Super Turbo Championship Edition adds two new levels that have been carefully inserted into the game so as to seem like they belonged there all along. It also provides new backstory with further insight into some of the game's characters, new enemies that test your skills even more and a second currency to collect, which is then used to unlock costumes that tweak your character's abilities.

On top of the additional content, DrinkBox has gone over the existing game with a magnifying glass, tweaking every encounter and perfecting the difficulty. Fights that were too easy now have more enemies spawn in. Difficulty spikes on the "normal" difficulty setting have been smoothed out.

Every piece of Guacamelee Super Turbo Championship Edition feels essential to the core game, even if I didn't realize that I wanted each of them. That's just about the highest praise I could give it; this is the best version of a great game.

9.0 PSN
Initial Review: 04/09/2013

Guacamelee review: back from hell

Back to top ^

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new Polygon username and password

As part of the new Polygon launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to Polygon going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new Polygon username and password

As part of the new Polygon launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to Polygon going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.



Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.