Having a highly unique opinion hardly makes it false. Also, I believe Megamatics meant to write it as “run-of-the-mill movie game” comparing it only to movie-like games and not necessarily every game ever made. I’ve actually found highly differing views among gamers when it comes to these highly cinematic games. I would expect a critic to rate it based on what it is (a rather perfect game in its category) but to someone not interested in the genre, the beauty and the “stunning” aspects may not do much for them. That just leaves the core gameplay which was good but also a pretty typical cover/shoot/sneak setup.