In each episode of Quality Control, Polygon managing editor Justin McElroy talks to a critic after they review a new game and allows them to add a little bit of extra context and insight. Why did they feel the way they did? What do they wish they had been able to discuss in more depth in their review? Also: Did they play it wrong?
Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker on the new Quality Control


In this episode, we talk with Arthur Gies about his review of Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker which you can find right here. We'd love to know what you think in the comments below!
- Read the review
- Subscribe to the podcast (RSS)
- Subscribe on iTunes
- Email: qualitycontrol at polygon dot com
- Music: Goodwill by The Custodian of Records
Most Popular
- All the new video games launching in 2026
- Cassian Andor says luck brought him this far. Obi-Wan Kenobi and Star Wars history disagree
- How Thunderbolts* evolved from a Die Hard movie into a Breakfast Club movie
- The fact that Lune from Clair Obscur is barefoot the whole time is not gross, it’s fun
- Thunderbolts*’ writer didn’t know Marvel cut his Taskmaster arc until he saw the movie











