clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Is this the death of the cable box?

Two and a half years ago, Microsoft finally took their first big step toward a goal it had been pursuing for nearly a decade: making your cable box obsolete.

This month, Microsoft showed off another major milestone in that fight: A season of television originals created to appeal to millennial gamers by Microsoft's internal Xbox Entertainment Studios.

This is, for better or worse, the birth of Xbox TV.

But it's important to recognize that Microsoft isn't interested in becoming your cable provider: That's a dead end. Microsoft knows it, companies like Hulu, Netflix and Amazon know it. There's even a lot of evidence that cable providers like Comcast know that the business of providing television shows locked to a specific day, a specific time, a specific device, is not long of this world.

The millennials, the hot generation that advertisers are dying to court, don't watch TV like the generations before it did. It's even hard to pin down their viewing habits. This according to Nancy Tellem, former CBS president and current head of entertainment and digital media at Microsoft.

So how does one capture an audience that doesn't care if they're watching their favorite television show when it airs or even if they're watching it on a television?

You embrace the ubiquity of content and remove the pointless barriers constructed between the sorts of visual entertainment people enjoy: gaming, television, movies, Twitch streaming, YouTube.

And that's exactly what Microsoft is trying to do, but at what cost?

It started, in many ways, in 2011 when Microsoft landed a deal that added cable provider apps to the Xbox 360. For Comcast, for instance, that started with 40 providers granting access to their television shows through a Comcast app for people with a cable subscription and an Xbox 360. Comcast was soon joined by the likes of HBO, Syfy, Netflix and others.

But it wasn't until this content came to the Xbox One that Microsoft's vision for the future of television started coming into focus.

Where Nintendo looked to fit in comfortably in your entertainment center with the Wii U, complementing experiences you already have in your den and online; where PlayStation looks to take advantage, with the PlayStation 4, of those other entertainment options you already own; Microsoft plans to conquer your den.

Ultimately, this is a console designed to be the entertainment hub of your household. But that conquest starts with baby steps.

Already, the Xbox One can control your cable box. The console can also deliver a guide, but not just a guide for what's on TV, but a guide for what's on your TV. That might include your favorite games, Netflix shows, Comcast channels, most certainly the upcoming wave of Xbox Originals.

It is a system designed to tear down the walls between mediums and create a level playing field for content, with Xbox as the gatekeeper.

And it's a smart plan.

I like the idea that I can allow friends to ping me when I'm playing Titanfall to ask me to come watch a show with them, or that they could interrupt a show to ask me to come game. I like that Microsoft, Netflix, Amazon and others are creating content that won't be tied to time slots, forcing me to watch when someone decides I should be watching.

I find Microsoft's experiments with commenting systems intriguing. That comments about a show can be tagged or time-shifted, to create a sense of community, a sense of watching with a crowd, even if I happen to watch a show at 3 a.m. on a Monday.

Giving viewers control of camera angles, of secondary information, of, perhaps, how an episode will play-out in real time, are all signs that Microsoft is deeply, philosophically invested in innovating in a medium that remains tied to some antiquated and annoying notions.

But I also fear that this innovation will come with a price.

Microsoft continues to promise they won't take advantage of the Kinect camera that comes with every single Xbox One. But given its abilities, it sounds like a device designed for audience measurement.

The new Kinect knows who's in a room when a show is being watched. It can track emotions of multiple people by watching facial expressions. It can tell when a viewer looks away from the TV.

This is the Nielsen ratings perfected, the Nielsen ratings without the need for sampling or to trust in viewers and their willingness and ability to fill out diaries.

Last week, when I pressed Tellem about use of the device, she first enthused about its usefulness and then quickly reminded me it wouldn't be used without direct audience permission.

I'm sure at some point Microsoft will figure out a reward system that will win over an audience open to the idea.

And that's the problem: Microsoft has a history of abusing the trust of its consumers be it through collusion with government spy networks, dishonesty about early Xbox 360 console reliability or its anti-trust issues in the 90s.

In looking to reinvent television and become its gatekeeper, Microsoft needs to also spend some time reinventing itself.

Good Game is an internationally syndicated weekly news and opinion column about the big stories of the week in the gaming industry and its bigger impact on things to come. Brian Crecente is a founding News Editor of Polygon.

The shows, tech and reasoning behind Microsoft's grand experiment with television

The next level of puzzles.

Take a break from your day by playing a puzzle or two! We’ve got SpellTower, Typeshift, crosswords, and more.