clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
A new Celestial stands above a battlefield, its red eyes gleaming, its fist raised with thumb held horizontal as it promises it will judge all beings on Earth. “If you are found lacking,” it intones, “there will be no tomorrow,” in AXE: Judgment Day #2 (2022). Image: Kieron Gillen, Valerio Schiti/Marvel Comics

Filed under:

Marvel Comics just solved the MCU’s Eternals problem, if anyone wants to fix it

The movies can and should steal from the best

If you buy something from a Polygon link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Susana Polo is an entertainment editor at Polygon, specializing in pop culture and genre fare, with a primary expertise in comic books. Previously, she founded The Mary Sue.

When Marvel Studios announced that it would bring the Eternals to the screen, not as secondary characters but in their own solo franchise, most people said, “Who?” But true Marvel Comics nerds said, “Why?

The Eternals have never really worked. Not when their creator, Jack Kirby, put them on the page as a retread of the more iconic Fourth World, and not when preeminent modern myth-maker Neil Gaiman teamed up with no less an artist than John Romita Jr. to give them an update. And they didn’t really work in Marvel Studios’ Eternals, a movie more fascinating for its ambition than its achievements.

So expectations for Kieron Gillen’s Eternals were low, even though his gods-walk-among-us-as-pop-stars magnum opus The Wicked + The Divine gave him the perfect resume to actually make something of the characters. I was looking forward to it greatly, and was still surprised by how much I enjoyed it, much less that it would lead with natural flow into a line-wide Marvel Comics crossover event that I could honestly recommend to the casual reader.

And it’s not too late — not too late at all — for the Marvel Cinematic Universe to rip the whole concept out of the funnybook pages and slap it up on the screen.

What else is happening in the pages of our favorite comics? We’ll tell you. Welcome to Monday Funnies, Polygon’s weekly list of the books that our comics editor enjoyed this past week. It’s part society pages of superhero lives, part reading recommendations, part “look at this cool art.” There may be some spoilers. There may not be enough context. But there will be great comics. (And if you missed the last edition, read this.)

AXE: Judgment Day Omega

Irakis of the Eternals — disguised in a hoodie and jeans — helps a family replace their flat tire in the rain. Only when they are driving away does the father of the family realize that Ikaris didn’t have a carjack in AXE: Judgment Day: Omega (2022). Image: Kieron Gillen, Guiu Vilanova/Marvel Comics

I’m using the finale of AXE: Judgment Day as an excuse to say that the Eternals-to-Judgment Day saga has surpassed “if you like superhero comics, read this” and reached “if you want to read a good comic, read Gillen and artist Esad Ribić’s Eternals followed by AXE: Judgment Day.” The idea that the story has finished with a whole cadre of Eternals out there doing minor acts of superheroing Robin Hood-style around the globe and then leaving town as the Sad Hulk music plays — that’s good stuff. That’s good setup for anyone else who wants to use these characters, either for continuation or as guest stars in other books!

I’m normally the last person to advocate for a movie franchise to directly adapt anything that just happened in comics, but the MCU Eternals established just enough of the bones of Judgment Day that it wouldn’t take much more to veer the franchise in the right direction. And if the MCU was going to take a chance on the Eternals before they got good, it might as well do it when they actually are.

Do a Powerbomb #6

The two leads stand unnerved on a levitating platform as the necromancer wrestling promoter says “You’re going to wrestle god [...] they’re a huge wrestling fan. So much so that they do it professionally.” in Do a Powerbomb #6 (2022). Image: Daniel Warren Johnson/Image Comics

Speaking of “welp, you gotta fight god now” plot lines, every month I read another issue of Do a Powerbomb and every month I’m mad that I have to do other things with my time than telling people they need to read Do a Powerbomb.

Batman: Urban Legends #21

“Any chance you can drop b—” Robin says into his earpiece and Wally West/the Flash arrives instantly, saying “What do you need?” Batman turns to him and says, smirking, “Want to help us build a Batmobile?” in Batman: Urban Legends #21 (2022). Image: Anthony Falcone, Michael Cho/DC Comics

Anthologies are always hit or miss — that’s the whole business plan of them, after all. One real banger of a story that balances out the rest, giving inexperienced creators or niche characters time to shine. Batman: Urban Legends #21, however, is the rare issue where I loved every included story. “The Wheelman of Gotham” (depicted above) takes first billing, with its crack writing and its Darwyn Cooke by way of Jiro Kuwata art. But then the issue continues with one of the only many recent attempts at a story about police brutality through the eyes of the Gotham police department that has actually worked for me, a neat enough mystery about Batman’s parents coming back to life, and part one of a story about Arkham Asylum’s new juvenile detention program for supervillain sidekicks, which I can’t wait to read more of.

Kaya #2

Kaya drags a lizard steed out of a rushing river with great effort. “By your own lizard law,” she growls at a pissed off lizard man, “she’s mine now,”  in Kaya #2 (2022). Image: Wes Craig/Image Comics

Head empty, no thoughts, only the concept of lizard law.

Wolverine #27

Beast and Wolverine trade barbs before Beast slits Wolverine’s throat in Wolverine #27 (2022). Image: Benjamin Percy, Juan José Ryp/Marvel Comics

Ever since writer Benjamin Percy took the helm of both Wolverine (what it says on the tin) and X-Force (Krakoa’s CIA program, wrapped up in all the bad things the comparison suggests), the two books have been on a slow-burn collision course. With this week’s issue, it looks like he might be ready to finally slam Beast and Wolverine into each other like two semitrucks going in opposite directions. It probably won’t have ripple effects much further than these two books, and probably nobody cares except people who’ve been reading both series this whole time. But I’ll still say it: It’s exciting.


The ultimate way to watch the Marvel movies


Marvel VFX workers vote ‘yes’ to unionize


The best and biggest comics coming up in fall 2023

View all stories in Marvel

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for Patch Notes

A weekly roundup of the best things from Polygon