clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
A mosaic collage of stills from The Bear, Succession, Blue Eye Samurai, Silo, and Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Graphic: Pete Volk/Polygon | Source images: Various

Filed under:

The best TV episodes of 2023

Weddings, fights, major malfunctions, and more

If you buy something from a Polygon link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

All TV is told through episodes, but not all episodes tell the best version of TV. In truth, the “best episodes” are a completely separate metric from the best shows — one tells the story of the whole, while the other examines how much a particular chapter was able to stand on its own.

Of course, what makes an episode a standout has a lot to do with the beholder — it could be because it’s particularly shocking or funny, monumental or contained, horrifying or titillating, vital to the plot or pure filler fun. The best episodes of television in 2023 run the gamut of genre and tone. But at the end of the day, the best episodes feel like something worth highlighting because of the particular delight of those chapters, the way each one feels representative — or even not particularly representative — of what the show does best.

Here are the best TV episodes of 2023.

[Ed. note: Some of these blurbs contain spoilers for the shows in question.]

Blue Eye Samurai season 1, episode 5, ‘The Tale of the Ronin and the Bride’

The Bride puppet rising above flames and other dead human puppets Image: Netflix

Blue Eye Samurai can be found on Netflix.

Blue Eye Samurai starts off as a good show, but by the time the fifth episode ends, it turns into a phenomenal one. “The Tale of the Ronin and the Bride” weaves together three stories — a flashback, a folk tale told via bunraku puppets, and the current impossible fight that the titular warrior, Mizu, faces. It’s an incredible episode, and one that uses the medium of animation to its full effect. The flashback helps the audience understand Mizu’s actions in the present day, and the folk tale allegorically ties both of the other storylines together. Also, the fight scenes are sick. —Petrana Radulovic

Silo season 1, episode 3, ‘Machines’

Rebecca Ferguson resting underground but looking pissed in Silo Image: Apple TV Plus

Silo can be found on Apple TV Plus.

Silo proved its worth with “Machines,” the third episode of season 1. Where the first two chapters were pensive character studies, “Machines” is a full-on thriller. Certain powers that be want Juliette (Rebecca Ferguson) to take over as sheriff of the silo. She’s game, on one condition: She’s allowed to shut down the generator to make crucial repairs. No one has attempted such a task — because failure could result in everyone in the silo losing power for good. And then also dying.

The core part of “Machines” plays out as a lengthy sequence with the taut intensity of a Mission: Impossible film. But it’s more quietly a showcase of Juliette’s unflappable grit — her magnetic defiant streak that gives Silo its narrative engine — delivered via one of the fiercest lines of the show: “Everyone thinks their job in the silo is the most important,” Juliette says. “Mine actually is.” Talk about knowing your worth. —Ari Notis

Jury Duty season 1, episode 8, ‘The Verdict’

The cast of Jury Duty sitting at a table looking bored and frustrated Image: Amazon Freevee

Jury Duty can be found on Freevee on Prime Video.

Magicians may frown upon anyone who reveals the secrets behind an illusion, but comedy writers aren’t so protective, especially when they’ve pulled off a banger. After towing mild-mannered juror Ronald Gladden through seven episodes of a hijinks-filled faux-trial, The Office veterans Lee Eisenberg and Gene Stupnitsky ended their hidden-camera sitcom Jury Duty with what amounts to the ultimate behind-the-scenes featurette. Making Jury Duty was a circus of production coordination, scenario building, and improvisation, all conducted from hidden corners of the courthouse. So while “The Verdict” still gave us a sweet coda for Ronald and fitting post-show reflection, it also deconstructed what amounted to a David Fincher-level operation pulled off on the fly. A stunning effort for a few chuckles. —Matt Patches

Succession season 4, episode 3, ‘Connor’s Wedding’

Kendall (Jeremy Strong) hugs Shiv (Sarah Snook) and Roman (Kieran Culkin) Image: HBO

Succession can be found on Max.

This was the big one, the episode that Succession had been building to since its opening minutes: the one where Logan dies. Brian Cox’s Logan Roy was a force of nature in every scene he was (dominating) in, but watching the fallout of his death, and getting each of his children’s unique reactions to it, was devastating and felt like a worthy culmination of the four seasons of family drama that preceded it. “Connor’s Wedding” was a high mark for the series’ rocky final season, and the last moment where every part of the show felt like it was firing on all cylinders. —Austen Goslin

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off season 1, episode 5, ‘Lights. Camera. Sparks?!’

Todd Ingraham as Scott Pilgrim standing and looking at a group of people Image: Netflix

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off can be found on Netflix.

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off is a fantastic reimagining of the original Scott Pilgrim movie, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (and a great backdoor sequel), and in no episode is its meta-commentary cleverness more evident than this one. During this faux-documentary episode about the disastrous making of the Scott Pilgrim movie, Takes Off deftly dodges back and forth between in-jokes about the film, and expansions of its own animated world. By the end of the episode, which includes Todd having a breakdown, Ramona fighting Wallace’s stunt doubles, and Envy Adams playing Ramona, the brilliant zaniness of Takes Off comes into perspective: This show can do basically anything it wants, and it will. —AG

The Bear season 2, episode 4, ‘Honeydew’

Lionel Boyce as Marcus watches Will Poulter as Luca tweeze something onto food Photo: Chuck Hodes/FX

The Bear can be found on Hulu.

We’re all entitled to our favorite episodes of The Bear, but I have the softest spot for Marcus (Lionel Boyce), and thus I adored “Honeydew” both as a focal point for his character, and also as a mellow, melancholic meditation — smack dab in between episodes that were more confrontational.

This is a man who started his culinary career as a cook at McDonald’s, and who has only recently allowed himself to experiment. It is a beautiful thing to see him grow under the tutelage of an accomplished baker — and also fascinating to see Marcus in a room with someone who has ascended so high in the culinary world, only to hear that person admit they’re “not the best.”

It made me think hard about the value of art — how we choose to excel in the craft, whether by competitive spirit or an intrinsic love — and how hard it is to allow yourself the vulnerability to yearn when you’ve only really had the resources and headspace to survive. A TV writer friend of mine recently mentioned that he didn’t love the “random” end of the episode, where Marcus rescues a man on a bike trapped under a gate: What even happens to that man? We never meet him again. I totally disagreed — to me, this emotional beat underlined that caring is a fact of Marcus’ character. Kindness often gets buried in Carmy’s hectic kitchen, but Marcus keeps it alive. It’s a gift. —Nicole Clark

The Bear season 2, episode 7, ‘Forks’

Andrew Lopez as Garret explaining something to Ebon Moss-Bachrach as Richie, who’s looking incredulous at him as they polish stemware Photo: Chuck Hodes/FX

The Bear can be found on Hulu.

As soon as The Bear’s second season revealed that it was going to be following different characters in (more or less) every episode, Richie stuck out like a sore thumb. Just like he says to Carmy in the restaurant’s basement early in the season, it’s not really clear where he fits in to all this or what he’s even good at. Luckily, The Bear knew exactly what to do with him. Watching Richie slowly learn the ropes of fine dining at a prestigious restaurant and find the ways he loves helping people and making them happy was perfect. Everything, from the echoes of him taking care of Tiff earlier in the season, to his conversation with Chef Terry (Olivia Colman) at the end of “Forks,” to him running out and buying a deep dish pizza, felt exactly in line with the character while still pushing him forward and growing him. It’s clean, elegant, fun characterization, and the standout episode of a season that was full of great ones. —AG

Game Changer season 5, episode 9, ‘Escape the Greenroom’

The cast of Gamechanger playing a game in the first episode of the fifth season Image: CH Media

Game Changer can be found on Dropout.

In Game Changer, host/antagonist Sam Reich traps improv performers within their own instincts, and it doesn’t get better than when those performers are testing boundaries or pushing back on their circus ringleader. So “Escape the Green Room,” in which Sam literally traps three unaware Dropout performers in a room, is the apex of the form. Decorum dissolves immediately. Every breakaway object in the room is smashed in a frenzy (plus some that are not, actually, breakaway items). The filming crew is offered $20 to kick an RC car. It’s madness, it’s joy, it’s worth the Dropout subscription all on its own. —Susana Polo

Chucky season 3, episode 3, ‘Jennifer’s Body’

Jennifer Tilly as Jennifer Tilly sitting in court Image: Syfy

Chucky can be found on Peacock.

In this episode, Oscar-nominated actress Jennifer Tilly (who is actually possessed by Chucky’s ex-girlfriend Tiffany) is charged with 103 counts of murder. Tilly’s gonzo performance as “Jennifer Tilly” is one of the highlights of the show, and the focus on her in the trial allows her fully committed performance to shine. The episode also guest-stars Kenan Thompson, who gets a particularly gruesome death via umbrella. And Chucky, in his quest to find the most evil house in order to undo his infection with “Christian magic” after a season 2 exorcism (this show rules), settles on the White House. It’s a typical day for Chucky, but in typical Chucky fashion, it’s a blast. —Pete Volk

The Continental season 1, episode 3, ‘Night 3: Theatre of Pain’

Mark Musashi as Hansel and Marina Mazepa as Gretel looking at the camera Image: Starz Entertainment

The Continental can be found on Peacock.

I was very skeptical entering the John Wick spinoff series The Continental; I wasn’t sure how much more detail that universe really needed. The first two installments were fun enough. But it was the third that really clicked for me — thanks to the strength of its great action sequences.

The show hired legendary action director Larnell Stovall to design the show’s action, and it really paid off, especially in the third episode. Pitting a contortionist (who played Gabriel in Malignant) against an MMA-trained actor was a stroke of genius, resulting in a rooftop confrontation that is among the best fights of the year. —PV

The Last of Us season 1, episode 3, ‘Long, Long Time’

Bill (Nick Offerman) stands awkwardly as Frank (Murray Bartlett) cheerfully pages through book of Linda Rondstadt sheet music, seated at a piano in The Last of Us. Photo: Liane Hentscher/HBO

The Last of Us can be found on Max.

HBO’s The Last of Us largely follows the main beats of Naughty Dog’s 2013 hit video game. If you played and loved the game, you might think the show is a little redundant, and you might even be right. But episode 3 of the adaptation, “Long, Long Time,” has something special the game didn’t. Bill and Frank’s relationship was only implied, and we never actually got to meet Frank — it was sort of a combination of the “bury your gays” trope and fridging. In the show, Frank’s ending still isn’t happy, but we actually get to meet and know him, and cry for him, over the course of an episode. Even if you skip the rest of the series, be sure to watch episode 3 — it gives life to a brief, sad section of the game, enhanced by both Murray Bartlett’s and Nick Offerman’s performances as two men who fall in love at the end of the world. —Kallie Plagge

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2, episode 2, ‘Ad Astra Per Aspera’

Una (Rebecca Romijn) stands and talks to someone Photo: Michael Gibson/Paramount Plus

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds can be found on Paramount Plus.

Star Trek has a love affair with the legal drama, and it’s not wrong. A trial bookended The Next Generation, produced some of the franchise’s greatest triumphs, and, though it took decades, is even responsible for Strange New Worlds existing in the first place.

It was ambitious for SNW to take a swing at its own “Measure of a Man.” But “Ad Astra Per Aspera” doesn’t merely equal the brief; it improves on the classic Star Trek trope of putting personhood on trial by keeping the captain out of the courtroom and the focus on the aggrieved minority, not their magnanimous savior. —SP

Poker Face season 1, episode 9, ‘Escape from Shit Mountain’

Natasha Lyonne as Charlie Cale and Stephanie Hsu as Morty standing in a convenience store Image: Peacock

Poker Face can be found on Peacock.

Every episode of Rian Johnson’s Columbo-derived murder-procedural series is its own little micro-movie, often tapping into different crime-movie subgenres. “Escape from Shit Mountain” is the Very Bad Things pastiche, the kind of story where a selfish, reckless person makes one bad decision, then doubles down on it, necessitating a whole host of further bad decisions to keep that first one under wraps.

In this case, the first bad decision comes from Trey (constant Rian Johnson collaborator Joseph Gordon-Levitt), a rich, terminally bored man under house arrest in a fancy chalet. By this point in Poker Face, the show’s format was getting familiar, but this episode stretches stylistically, with a Blood Simple-esque neo-noir look and nervy montage editing, and structurally, with a story that downplays Charlie’s shamus role, and instead puts her into one mesmerizingly dangerous, unpredictable situation after another. It’s breakneck, breathless storytelling, with a terrific cameo from Everything Everywhere All at Once’s Stephanie Hsu and the entire series’ most unnerving episode ending. —Tasha Robinson

How To with John Wilson season 3, episode 5, ‘How to Watch Birds’

A car on fire in a parking lot in a still from How To with John Wilson Photo: Thomas Wilson/HBO

How to with John Wilson can be found on Max.

John Wilson’s wistful camera-rolling approach to life has made him a distinct voice in documentary storytelling — but even he was bound to get tired after landing the opportunity of a lifetime making his own show at HBO. Fans knew it was over the minute “How to Watch Birds” premiered; the guy who made his bones on capturing unfettered reality pulled the rug from under his audience’s feet, making them question everything, as they should. An F for Fake for the aging hipster demo, “How to Watch Birds” starts with a typical inquiry and ends with a car explosion. Even a show that could only exist with a filmmaker as curious as Wilson still needs a little of that fabricated push of modern TV-making to tell its stories, and Wilson lays it all out for his audience to see, which happens to involve a lot of simulated poop. —MP

Reservation Dogs season 3, episode 6, ‘Frankfurter Sandwich’

Lane Factor as Cheese fishing in a still from Reservation Dogs season 3 Photo: Shane Brown/FX

Reservation Dogs can be found on Hulu.

There are too many great episodes to choose from in Reservation Dogsexcellent final season, my favorite show of the year. There’s the one where Bear meets long-lost community member Maximus in the desert. Or the heartbreaking episode about the Deer Lady’s childhood. Or the one about the elders as kids. Or the one where Elora meets her dad. The list goes on!

But my favorite is “Frankfurter Sandwich,” where Cheese, avoiding his friends, is sent out by his grandmother to hang out with the uncles. The group goes on a camping trip together, in a very sweet and funny episode that expands on the season’s interest in cross-generational relationships and what we can learn from each other. —PV

Hilda season 3, episode 8, ‘The Fairy Isle’

Hilda and her friends ride puffy creatures Image: Netflix

Hilda can be found on Netflix.

Hilda is one of those phenomenal animated children’s shows that also appeals to adult viewers. It stars the young, plucky Hilda (Bella Ramsey), who lives in Trolberg with her mom, and who has a penchant for exploring nature — and getting into trouble. But none of its themes are one-note. Sometimes Hilda wins and sometimes she loses, and that is the very joy of life itself.

The third season focuses on the deepest mystery of the show: who Hilda’s family is. The answer to where she really came from is beautifully revealed in the finale, in a heavy episode that gives meaning to everything that comes before it. And while it’s always sad when a favorite show comes to an end, I love the intentionality with which this finale was crafted — down to the cameos of characters from previous episodes, shown in a kind of ending montage, as if to signal, “Hilda may be over, but her adventures will go on.” It feels like graduating. —NC

Invincible season 2, episode 3, ‘This Missive, This Machination’

Mark Grayson sitting and looking despondently at his mask Image: Prime Video

Invincible can be found on Prime Video.

The third episode of Invincible’s second season has a lot going on. There’s a prologue about Allen the Alien, and a strong B-plot about Debbie attending a support group. A shape-shifting alien shows up disguised as the ridiculous comic book character Seance Dog, leading to some hilarious antics between Mark and his roommate.

But that’s all a bait and switch for its ultimate aim: a dramatic, surprising reunion between father and son. The ensuing conflict, which continues into the (also excellent) fourth episode, does not shy away from Mark’s anger toward his father, or his pain. But because this is Invincible, those feelings have to be balanced against a surprise threat, forcing an unlikely and emotional team-up.

The third episode is where Invincible’s second season really hit its stride. Now we just have to suffer the wait for part 2. —PV

The Other Two season 2, episode 6, ‘Brooke, and We Are Not Joking, Goes to Space’

Brooke (Heléne York) looks incredulous at a Jeff Bezos-type leaning across the table at her Photo: Greg Endries/Max

The Other Two can be found on Max.

Chris Kelly and Sarah Schneider’s Hollywood-skewering comedy hit so many highs this season as it vaulted from the deranged into the surreal, but nothing hit as hard as Cary Dubek (Drew Tarver) standing in a fabulous Billy Porter-ready dress watching as he’s the victim of a classic movie studio gay fakeout. While the title nods to Brooke’s date with a Jeff Bezos stand-in, it’s Cary landing the role of Globby, the “first openly queer character” in a Disney Animated film, that cracks all the show’s themes: big breaks, friend-group sacrifices, selling out your identity, and whether globs of green goo can have sex. Laced with sadness but packed with jokes, the half hour is exactly what The Other Two does so well and what will be sorely missed when nothing comes to take the now-concluded series’ place. —MP

Only Murders in the Building, season 3 episode 8, ‘Sitzprobe’

Steve Martin standing and singing in front of a music stand with people seated behind him on a theater stage in Only Murders in the Building Photo: Patrick Harbron/Hulu

Only Murders in the Building can be found on Hulu.

This season of Only Murders in the Building was pretty light on the detective work and leaned more on the theater drama of it all. But the best episode made use of both these elements, seamlessly blending Charles (Steve Martin), Oliver (Martin Short), and Mabel (Selena Gomez) investigating the murder with the dry run of Death Rattle Dazzle. It culminates in Charles belting out his patter song — a completely infectious number that he infamously flubbed over and over again in previous episodes — while Oliver pulls off the sneakiest subterfuge yet. It’s everything the show does best, and I still can’t get “Which of the Pickwick Triplets Did It?” out of my head. —PR

Mrs. Davis season 1, episode 3, ‘A Baby With Wings, a Sad Boy With Wings and a Great Helmet’

Jake McDorman as Wiley standing and touching a sword Photo: Sophie Kohler/Peacock

Mrs. Davis can be found on Peacock.

Tara Hernandez and Damon Lindelof’s Mrs. Davis goes ridiculously far afield in its story, jumping from the Crusades to the modern-day Vatican to a desert island to a Vegas magic act to a modern-day nunnery. But episode 3 does the best job of defining the careful tone of that weirdness, as paranoid cowboy Wiley (Jake McDorman) completely derails the show’s central quest to participate in an absurd endurance contest known as “Excalibattle.” The episode leaps back and forth in time as Mrs. Davis so often does, filling in backstory on the complicated, fraught relationships that series protagonist Simone (Betty Gilpin) has with Wiley and others.

But the real joy of this episode is how hard it leans into Wiley’s spontaneous obsession with an event that’s both ridiculous and painfully mundane, and how convincingly it explores the lengths people will go to when they’re trying to erase past shames and live up to their own self-images. The whole episode seems to be laughing at Wiley, and at macho self-aggrandizing in general — and yet it’s sympathetic as well, both to his struggles with his past, and to his impulsive, desperate attempt to find a fix that helps him live with himself. —TR

The Devil’s Plan season 3, episode 3, ‘Episode 3’

Contestants in The Devil’s Plan sitting around a table in the pilot Image: Netflix

The Devil’s Plan can be found on Netflix.

Like any good competitive reality TV show, The Devil’s Plan was at its best when showcasing players forming alliances in order to gain strategic advantages and more gold pieces (the game’s internal currency). And while nearly every game in the season forced players to work together — there’s everything from a version of Mafia to a hidden object memory game — episode 3’s collective board game was a true highlight.

Groups immediately split into two factions, realizing they could create interlocking rules to screw each other over. One group formed a strategy for forcing their opponents backward; the other attempted to anticipate what that group was doing, and failed entirely. It was thrilling to watch the rigmarole of more than 10 people work together with limited resources while lying to each other’s faces. As in any great competitive reality TV show, the drama all played out in the game. —NC

Schmigadoon! season 2, episode 5, ‘Famous as Hell’

Schmigadoon! can be found on Apple TV Plus.

Parodying ’60s and ’70s Broadway musicals like Chicago and Cabaret let Cinco Paul and Ken Daurio’s Schmigadoon get sharper, more confident, and more enjoyably weird in season 2 than it was in season 1, which channeled sunnier, earlier musicals from Brigadoon to The Music Man. Every episode in season 2 has at least one hilarious, irresistible earworm. But the whole thing comes together most clearly in episode 5, “Famous As Hell,” which finds more space for the supporting cast — particularly Alan Cumming and Kristin Chenoweth.

The title number is the highlight, as the central couple, Melissa (Cecily Strong) and Josh (Keegan-Michael Key), stranded in a magical musical realm, drop their objections to the place and start getting comfortable. Melissa earns a fervent fandom in a cabaret out of Cabaret, and Josh becomes the hero of a flower-child cult out of Godspell. Suddenly, a pretty silly show that’s approximately one-tenth about navigating life’s disappointments and nine-tenths about Broadway in-jokes finds a sharper focus. It becomes much more of a story about the temptations of escapism and easy answers — which Tituss Burgess underlines as as a fourth-wall-breaking singing narrator equally channeling Pippin’s narrator and Judas from Jesus Christ Superstar, and absolutely devouring armloads of scenery every time he appears. “It was a rhetorical questionnnnnnn!” —TR