First off, let me say that I am hugely impressed with the re-design of the site. I've followed Polygon since the Verge days, and I really appreciate the content that you create, and the way you present it. It really feels fresh, modern, and fast.
The only gripe I have is with the presentation of review scores in the new design. Previously, it was really easy to visually process what the score of a game was, as the circle was "closed" only as far as the score went. The new visual is a fully closed circle, leading me to think that every single game has scored a perfect 10. I know the actual score is presented in the number, but the overall visual was previously easier to comprehend, at least for me.
If I'm just being a grumpy old man, then I guess I'll get used to the new look in a bit :) The old presentation is also still used if you go to the Reviews section of the site.
Attaching screenshot to show what I'm referring to: Visual score